Perfect Coconut Cream Pie Recipe on Food52 (2024)

Make Ahead

by: em-i-lis

March16,2021

4.5

6 Ratings

  • Makes 1 pie

Jump to Recipe

Author Notes

Coconut cream pie is one of my all-time favorite desserts. The small Louisiana town in which I grew up had a real cafeteria, one of those old-fashioned joints where you grab a tray and head down the line, picking up pre-plated dishes as you go. I often got the "sides" plate -- smothered greens, fried okra, mac & cheese -- and a wedge of coconut cream pie or, when they had it, caramel custard in a cup (another favorite). My mom, sister, grandma and I spent so many happy lunches at that cafeteria, and even though it's not quite as good as it used to be, and caramel custard in a cup days are still too rare, I love the nostalgia of the dining-in experience, and I go back each time I visit home.

Recently, I thought about how long it'd been since I'd had coconut cream pie, especially a really good, homemade one that's ethereally light and a full-on tribute to the delicate, unique flavor that is coconut. What can one do in that instance but get busy making one?

Extremely long story short, I used my family pie crust recipe (which cannot be beat), made homemade sweetened, shredded coconut (a recipe I found on the Livestrong site) to avoid the chemicals sometimes found in commercially processed sweetened coconut, and adapted pastry cream and topping recipes from Epicurious. The result was perfection, and my hubby and I wiped the pie out in two days flat! This pie definitely wants a night in the fridge to set and let the flavors deepen, so make it a day in advance if you can. —em-i-lis

Test Kitchen Notes

This coconut cream pie is full of natural goodness. I love how it is full of coconut flavor, yet not too sweet, and the pie is really easy to make. Next time, I will cut the salt in the crust to perhaps 1/2 teaspoon only. The pie is delicious and has a great coconut flavor due to the canned coconut milk and the homemade sweetened coconut. I will definitely make this again! —Robin Burton Fenner

  • Test Kitchen-Approved

What You'll Need

Ingredients
  • For the pie crust and sweetened coconut
  • 2 cupsall-purpose flour, sifted
  • 1 1/2 teaspoonssalt
  • 1/2 cupcanola oil
  • 1/4 cupmilk
  • 2 cupsshredded, unsweetened, dried coconut
  • 4 tablespoonspowdered sugar, sifted
  • 6 teaspoonscanola oil
  • 8 teaspoonswater
  • For the pastry cream and topping
  • 1/2 cupplus 2 tablespoons sugar, divided
  • 2 large eggs plus 1 large egg yolk
  • 3 tablespoonsall-purpose flour
  • 1 can full-fat coconut milk, divided
  • One batch sweetened coconut, divided
  • 1 teaspoonvanilla extract
  • 1 cupchilled whipping cream
Directions
  1. For the pie crust and sweetened coconut
  2. Preheat the oven to 350. In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together the sifted flour and salt. Pour in the oil and milk, and using a fork, stir to combine. When the dough comes together, roll it out between two sheets of waxed paper, peel off the top sheet, and invert the crust over and into a deep-dish pie plate. Press the crust in and all the way up the sides, and trim off the excess.
  3. Fill with pie weights or line with foil topped with dried beans, and bake until golden and set, 25 to 30 minutes. Let cool completely.
  4. While the pie crust is cooking and cooling, make the sweetened coconut: In a medium mixing bowl, toss together the shredded coconut and the sifted powdered sugar until well combined. In a separate small bowl, stir together the oil and water until well combined and then pour over the sugared coconut. Stir gently to coat the coconut completely. Let sit for about 10 minutes, stirring and fluffing occasionally. The original amount will expand slightly in size. Refrigerate the sweetened coconut until you need it.
  1. For the pastry cream and topping
  2. Toast 2/3 cups of your sweetened coconut in a small, heavy skillet over medium heat until lightly browned, stirring occasionally, about 3 minutes. Let cool completely while you make the pastry cream.
  3. Whisk together 1/2 cup of sugar, the eggs, egg yolk, and flour in a medium bowl and set aside (but near the stove). In a medium saucepan set over medium heat, bring 1 1/2 cups of coconut milk and 1 1/2 cups of your sweetened coconut to a simmer. Gradually add this hot milk mixture to your egg mixture, whisking constantly.
  4. Return everything to the same saucepan; cook until pastry cream thickens and boils, stirring constantly, about 4 minutes.
  5. Remove from heat. Mix in the vanilla extract. Transfer pastry cream to a medium bowl. Cover with plastic wrap, pressing it directly onto the surface to prevent formation of skin. Chill until cold, at least 2 hours.
  6. When cold, transfer the filling to your prebaked, now-cool crust. Cover and chill while you make the topping.
  7. Using an electric hand mixer, beat the cream, the remaining 1/4 cup coconut milk, and the remaining 2 tablespoons of sugar in a medium bowl until peaks form. Spread whipped cream all over the top of pastry cream filling. Sprinkle evenly with cooled toasted coconut. Cover and refrigerate at least four hours, but preferably overnight.

Tags:

  • Pie
  • American
  • Coconut
  • Milk/Cream
  • Make Ahead
  • Summer
  • Memorial Day
  • Father's Day
  • Mother's Day
  • Easter
  • Valentine's Day
  • Fourth of July
Contest Entries
  • Your Best Coconut
  • Your Best Recipe with Coconut
  • The Recipe You're Most Proud Of

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Nicole Christina Hild-e

  • catalinalacruz

  • luvcookbooks

  • monacake

  • JanetFL

Popular on Food52

51 Reviews

Mcswain27 September 21, 2020

I’m not sure what wrong for me - the filling came out more like a paste then a pastry cream. I think it needed a lot more liquid then just a can of coconut milk. If I did it again I’d probably add a cup of milk as well.

em-i-lis September 21, 2020

How odd! I've never had that happen before!

Jocelyn August 29, 2020

I am excited to try making this pie. F52 is my go-to for recipes. Love the reviews with different suggestions. I have never made a homemade crust nor a Coconut Pie. My Mom is turning 80 years old on September 2nd. We will be celebrating my Mom's birthday Labor Day weekend. I will take a picture and let you know how it went to make the pie. Thank you for sharing.

LKT May 16, 2018

Custard was a little stiff, maybe use the whole can of coconut milk next time and have just plain whipped cream on top. The crust was crispy, very savory, and easy to roll out (used plastic wrap instead of wax paper as I didn’t have any on hand) but ultimately I prefer a regular butter or butter/crisco crust. The vegetable oil version was a little dense.

Nicole September 4, 2017

This is a beautiful recipe and easy to follow. I've made it twice and on the second attempt used low fat coconut milk - not worth it. Follow the instructions and use full fat. While the flavor was good, the custard and whipped cream was not nearly as luscious as my first attempt.

em-i-lis September 4, 2017

I'm so glad you like this pie, Nicole. It's one of my very favorites. I fully agree that low fat coconut milk is not the way to go here!! Have a great day!

Robbie June 27, 2017

I have been making this crust for over 50 years and it is my grandmother's recipe so our family has been making it over for over 75 years only we use pure vegetable oil (Crisco). This is the first time I have ever seen this recipe in print. I am very excited to try the rest of the recipe.

em-i-lis June 27, 2017

Hi Robbie,
So nice to hear this crust is part of your family traditions too. My grandparents owned a restaurant, and just after the war years came across this crust recipe at a restaurant convention. Written by Wesson, it was marketed as the crust you could make when butter was rationed. I myself much prefer it to butter crusts (for dessert pies anyway). :) Take good care! Emily

judy March 31, 2017

Wonderful--even the crust. I chose not to sweeten the coconut. And it worked great. The pie was sweet enough without sweetening the coconut as well. I've been looking for a great coconut pie recipe using coconut milk. Thanks a bunch.

em-i-lis March 31, 2017

Hi Judy, I'm so happy you enjoyed this pie. It's one of my very favorites. Definitely a labor of love but, I think, worth it. :) Thank you so much for trying it and for letting me know you enjoyed it!! All best, Emily

alaparc November 26, 2016

I made this pie for Thanksgiving as a request. It is truly outstanding - great coconut flavor without being cloyingly sweet. Crust worked well with the pie. I almost used a butter crus and glad I didn't.

em-i-lis November 26, 2016

Hi alaparc, I'm SO happy you made and loved this pie. Thanks so much for letting me know. Hope you had a great TG!

Nicole C. June 18, 2016

Any tips for better crust? I'm having a heck of a time rolling the dough out, as it is crumbling every which way. I've even added more oil and milk, but nothing is working!

em-i-lis June 18, 2016

Hi Nicole, This crust is simply but finicky and can really be rolled out no more than 2-3 times. I'm sorry you're having a rough go of it. You might want to start over, mix the ingredients very gently and only until just combined and then roll out between waxed paper. You should not need additional liquid as that can impair the texture. Good luck!!!!

Nicole C. June 18, 2016

Thanks, I'll give it another shot!

Michell H. June 16, 2016

Why does the filling taste eggy?

em-i-lis June 18, 2016

I've never had that experience- did you use full-fat coconut milk?

Michell H. June 21, 2016

Yes, I did

Melissa R. July 4, 2016

You most likely scalded the eggs a bit when transferring the mixtures. Try adding it a little slower next time. It took me a lot of practice!

catalinalacruz May 4, 2014

Why not use coconut oil in the pastry mix instead of canola oil, and have more coconut flavor?

em-i-lis May 4, 2014

why not?! go for it.

luvcookbooks November 30, 2013

Made this w my daughter to take to a Thanksgiving dinner and it was divine!!

em-i-lis November 30, 2013

Oh, awesome, Meg! Thanks for letting me know! I do love that recipe!!

Ceege September 15, 2013

I made this yesterday and it was simply divine. Thanks for a wonderful recipe. BTW, to make things easier, 6 tsps. equal 2 TBLS, so easier to measure it that way for the coconut mixture.

em-i-lis September 16, 2013

Thanks so much, Ceege. I'm thrilled you enjoyed the pie so much, and yes, good shorthand for the coconut mixture!!!

catalinalacruz August 28, 2013

Oil pie crust is awesome when it is made with coconut oil -- the only way I make pie crusts now. As this is a coconut cream pie, try using coconut oil for an extra coconut flavor.

em-i-lis September 16, 2013

Sounds like a great thing to try!

Muse August 25, 2013

Have been looking for a recipe for the perfect coconut creme pie....can't wait to make this! Yummy, yum, yum! Peace, Light and Love.

em-i-lis August 25, 2013

Thanks so much, Muse! I hope you love it like we do!! Let me know. Best, Emily

monacake August 23, 2013

when a co-worker asked for coconut cream pie for her birthday this week, i knew right where to go. i trusted that this would be the perfect recipe and it did not fail. better than the dozens that have come before it. everything about it is perfect - thank you!

em-i-lis August 23, 2013

Hi monacake, thank you so much for this lovely note! I'm thrilled the pie was such a birthday treat! And I appreciate you letting me know! All the best, Emily

J M. June 16, 2013

What am I doing wrong? I click on the Save button but when I look at my recipe box I see no recipes. I am signed in.

em-i-lis June 16, 2013

have you tried logging out or shutting your browser and then logging back in? i sometimes have delayed responses on F52 too but generally the saves and edits ultimately are there...

claude R. June 17, 2013

check your account on the top right

JanetFL June 15, 2013

Yum, Emily! Somehow I missed this recipe. I definitely am trying this - thank you!

em-i-lis June 15, 2013

Hi Janet, It's so lovely to hear from you and I'm glad you plan to try this!! Let me know what you think. :)

Sugartoast June 15, 2013

I'm going to make this soon, it looks amazing :). Thanks for another great recipe!

em-i-lis June 15, 2013

thank you so much, sugartoast! i hope you love it!! :)

em-i-lis June 14, 2013

Thanks so much for highlighting my pie, F52! I made one a few days back and we all gobbled it up!

Almyra P. June 14, 2013

Hi! Can anyone pls tell me about the metric measurement for the coconut milk. I live where coconut is very abundant and there's nobody selling coconut milk by the can. Thanks

em-i-lis June 14, 2013

In total, you'll need about 14 ounces, or roughly 400 grams.

Perfect Coconut Cream Pie Recipe on Food52 (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fredrick Kertzmann

Last Updated:

Views: 6202

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fredrick Kertzmann

Birthday: 2000-04-29

Address: Apt. 203 613 Huels Gateway, Ralphtown, LA 40204

Phone: +2135150832870

Job: Regional Design Producer

Hobby: Nordic skating, Lacemaking, Mountain biking, Rowing, Gardening, Water sports, role-playing games

Introduction: My name is Fredrick Kertzmann, I am a gleaming, encouraging, inexpensive, thankful, tender, quaint, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.